Comparative Effectiveness of Migraine Preventive Medications: The APT Comparison Study
A Comparative Effectiveness Study of Oral Medications Used for Migraine Prevention: The APT Comparison Study
Who can join
As published by the study on ClinicalTrials.gov. "Not stated" means the study hasn't said — ask the study team.
- Age
- 18 Years to 70 Years
- Sex
- All sexes
- Healthy volunteers
- Not accepted
- Compensation
- Not stated
Other requirements are listed under Eligibility below. Only the study team can confirm whether you can join.
What to expect
No one can promise a trial will help you personally — that is what the research is trying to find out.
What participation involves
- Time periods mentioned: 4 weeks, 12 weeks
Only what the study's summary and detailed description on ClinicalTrials.gov say. Time periods may describe the whole study or a part of it — ask the study team what applies to you.
Show the study's own words
- "Eligible participants will provide information in a daily headache diary for four weeks."
- "If after those four weeks they are still eligible for the study, they will be randomized to one of the study medications and receive study medication for twelve weeks."
- Compensation
- Not stated
- Study-related exams and procedures are typically provided at no cost. This is how many trials work in general — confirm the details for this study with the study team.
- Participants are monitored closely by the research team throughout the study.
- Some participants may receive access to an investigational treatment, which is still being studied.
- Your participation helps researchers learn whether this approach could help future patients.
About this study
In plain language
This study compares three medicines to prevent migraines: atogepant, topiramate, and propranolol. It will test which works better and causes fewer problems in adults ages 18–70 with migraines. Participants are assigned a medicine by chance and track their headaches in a daily diary and at study visits.
This goal of this study is to compare three medications used for migraine preventive treatment. This study will compare atogepant, a newer migraine preventive medication, with two older preventive medications, topiramate and propranolol. It will be determined if one works better and is more tolerable than the others. Research participants will: * Be randomly assigned to one of the three medications. * Provide information about their migraine pattern using a daily headache diary and during research visits.
Compensation is read from the study's own description and may be missing — always confirm with the study team.
Eligibility
Who can join
- You are 18–70 years old.
- You have a migraine diagnosis, with or without aura (changes in sight or other senses), or chronic migraines. Daily or nonstop headaches are allowed.
- Your migraines began before age 50 and have lasted at least 12 months.
- You have at least 4 moderate to severe headache days a month, confirmed with a 4-week diary. A day counts if the headache lasts at least 4 hours or you take a migraine-specific medicine to treat it.
- If you already use a migraine prevention treatment, you agree to keep the same dose for the first 16 weeks.
- You are not pregnant or breastfeeding. Women who can become pregnant must agree to use effective birth control.
- You can and agree to give informed consent, meaning you understand the study and agree to join.
- You can and agree to complete all study visits.
Who can't join
- You cannot safely take, or are unwilling to take, any of the three study medicines.
- You currently take or previously took atogepant, propranolol, or topiramate. Occasional propranolol use as needed, such as for anxiety, is allowed.
- You currently use a CGRP-targeting migraine prevention medicine or a beta-blocker, a type of medicine often used for blood pressure.
- You have brainstem aura (symptoms linked to the base of the brain), hemiplegic migraine (with muscle weakness), retinal migraine (vision changes in one eye), only aura without headache, or migraines only during menstrual periods.
- You have trigeminal autonomic cephalalgias (headaches with symptoms such as eye watering), facial nerve pain, or headaches caused by another condition. Headaches from overusing medicine are allowed.
- You started a migraine prevention treatment or changed its dose within the past 12 weeks.
- You used opioids or butalbital on an average of 5 or more days a month for at least the past 3 months.
- You have or have had epilepsy (a seizure disorder), have severe liver problems, or have moderate or worse kidney problems.
Simplified for readability. The official criteria below are what the study team uses.
Official eligibility criteria
Inclusion Criteria: * Adults, 18-70 years of age at the time of enrollment * Migraine with aura, migraine without aura, and/or chronic migraine; according to ICHD-3 diagnostic criteria. (Those with daily or continuous headaches are not excluded.) * Migraine onset prior to 50 years of age * Migraine present for at least 12 months at the time of enrollment * At least four "moderate to severe headache days" per month (by patient self-report and then confirmed during four-week pre-randomization headache diary phase) A "moderate to severe headache day" is defined as a day during which there is a headache of moderate to severe intensity that lasts for at least four hours, or a day on which a migraine-specific acute medication is taken to treat headache. * If already taking a migraine preventive treatment, willing to continue with that treatment without dose change during the first 16 weeks of the study, including the 4-week run-in phase and 12-week randomized phase. * Not pregnant or breastfeeding * Women of childbearing potential must agree to use effective methods of contraception to reduce the risk of pregnancy. * Willingness and ability to provide informed consent. * Willingness and ability to complete all research visits. Exclusion Criteria: * Contraindications to taking atogepant, propranolol, or topiramate. * Currently taking atogepant, propranolol, or topiramate\* * Previously took atogepant, propranolol, or topiramate\* * Unwillingness to take atogepant, topiramate, or propranolol. * Current use of a CGRP-targeting preventive medication or beta-blocker * Migraine with brainstem aura * Hemiplegic migraine * Retinal migraine * Migraine aura without headache (exclusively) * Pure menstrual migraine * Trigeminal autonomic cephalalgias * Facial neuralgias * Secondary headache disorders (medication overuse headache is not an exclusion) * Migraine preventive treatment has been started or dose has been changed within 12 weeks prior to potential enrollment. * Used opioids or butalbital on five or more days per month on average for at least 3 months prior to enrollment. * Current or past epilepsy * Severe hepatic impairment * Moderate or more severe renal impairment \* Occasional as needed use of propranolol, currently or in the past, is not an exclusion, such as taking as needed propranolol for treatment of anxiety.
Study sites (37)
AL
- Apogee Clinical Research · Hazel Green, AL 35750Shelby Lessman · Study contact · 256-827-5050 · slessmann@apogeecr.comJesslyn Roesch · Study contact · 256-827-5050 · jroesch@apogeecr.comLaura L Taylor, MD · Principal investigatorViktoriya Nelson, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Hazel Green
AZ
- Northern Arizona Healthcare · Flagstaff, AZ 86001Julie Kenkel, RN · Study contact · 928-779-3366 · Julie.Kenkel@nahealth.comJustin DeLange, D.O. · Principal investigatorMore trials in Flagstaff
- Mayo Clinic Arizona · Phoenix, AZ 85054Dani C Smith, MS · Study contact · 480-342-6524 · Smith.Dani@Mayo.eduMichael Leonard, MDiv · Study contact · 480-342-2908 · Leonard.Michael@Mayo.eduTodd Schwedt, MD · Principal investigatorJuliana VanderPluym, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Phoenix
CA
- Keck School of Medicine of USC · Los Angeles, CA 90033Rama Koppula · Study contact · 323-865-1020 · rk_198@usc.eduSoma Sahai-Srivastava, MD · Principal investigatorGautum Ganguly, MD · Sub-investigatorAna Gjurgevich, NP-C · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Los Angeles
- Clinical Research Institute · Los Angeles, CA 90048Ana Duchenko · Study contact · 323-879-9999 · aduchenko@clinicalri.netSandy Velasquez · Study contact · 323-879-9999 · svelasquez@clinicalri.netDavid Kudrow, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in Los Angeles
- Desert Physicians Medical Group · Palm Springs, CA 92262Cindy Ramirez · Study contact · 760-459-2193 · cindy@dpmgcr.comDario Kuzmanovic · Study contact · 909-547-7178 · dario.kuzmanovic@dpmghealth.comGemma Kim, MD · Principal investigatorAndy Tran, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Palm Springs
- The Neurology Group · Pomona, CA 91767Ikram Rfifa, BS · Study contact · 951-768-2352 · ikram@amctrials.comSheraz Mossa, BS · Study contact · 858-761-1090 · Sheraz@amctrials.comSamer Kebbeh, MD · Principal investigatorBhupat Desai, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Pomona
CO
- University of Colorado Anschutz Medical Campus · Aurora, CO 80045Adam Angelich · Study contact · 303-724-5923 · adam.angelich@cuanschutz.eduTrey Jouard · Study contact · 303-724-0920 · TREY.JOUARD@CUANSCHUTZ.EDUNicole Caunt, MD · Principal investigatorDanilee WIlhour, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Aurora
FL
- Memorial Healthcare · Hollywood, FL 33021Elisa Serantes · Study contact · 954 265-4184 · elserantes@mhs.netPiret Baldwin · Study contact · 954-265-6653 · Pibaldwin@mhs.netMaike Blaya, MD · Principal investigatorBrigitte E Farnsworth, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Hollywood
- Mayo Clinic Florida · Jacksonville, FL 32066Tinsae Dana · Study contact · 904-953-4259 · Dana.Tinsae@mayo.eduTInsae Dana · Study contact · Dana.Tinsae@mayo.eduOlga Fermo, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in Jacksonville
- Apple Med Research · Miami, FL 33126Carlos M Manzano · Study contact · 305-667-8434 · c26applemed@aol.comLillibeth Paz · Study contact · 305-667-8434 · l.paz@applemedresearch.orgAgustin L Latorre, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in Miami
- University of Miami · Miami, FL 33136Lilli Resto · Study contact · 305-243-1485 · Lxr1013@miami.eduDaniella Estevez · Study contact · 305-243-1485 · d.estevez1@miami.eduTeshamae Monteith, MD · Principal investigatorLiza Smirnoff, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Miami
KS
- Neuroscience Research Center · Overland Park, KS 66210Amy Reinert · Study contact · (913) 825-2314 · amy.r@neuroscienceresearchctr.comNeda Ahmad · Study contact · (913) 825-2315 · neda.a@neuroscienceresearchctr.comMayank Gupta, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in Overland Park
MA
- Clinical Trials of New England · Hyde Park, MA 02136Kenny Carberry · Study contact · 617-827-1803 · KCarberry@ClinicalTrialsNE.comWonji Shin · Study contact · WShin@clinicaltrialsne.comMichael Lowney, DO · Principal investigatorShannon Kriehn, NP · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Hyde Park
MN
- Mayo Clinic · Rochester, MN 55905Terrell Rieken · Study contact · 507-422-6561 · rieken.terrell@mayo.eduIzzie Meunier · Study contact · 507-538-6337 · Headlee.Amy@mayo.eduChia-Chun Chiang, MD · Principal investigatorNarayan Kissoon, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Rochester
MO
- Washington University St Louis · St Louis, MO 63110Alyssa Hiserote · Study contact · calyssa@wustl.eduAngela Wolford · Study contact · angelaw@wustl.eduRachel Darken, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in St Louis
NC
- Onsite Clinical Solutions Park Cedar Dr. · Charlotte, NC 28210Zoe Landingin · Study contact · 800-785-3150 ext. 1130 · zlandingin@onsiteclinical.comSummer Evans · Study contact · 800-785-3150 ext. 1034 · Sevans@onsiteclinical.comKenneth Ashkin, MD · Principal investigatorSydney Grey, PA-C · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Charlotte
- Onsite Clinical Solutions Mecklenburg · Charlotte, NC 28211Megan Hazlitt · Study contact · 800-785-3150 ext. 1002 · mhazlitt@onsiteclinical.comAlexis Adams · Study contact · 800-785-3150 ext. 1198 · aadams@onsiteclinical.comGeorge Raad, MD · Principal investigatorMichael Amiri, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Charlotte
- Onsite Clinical Solutions Ballantyne · Charlotte, NC 28277Summer Evans · Study contact · 800-785-3150 ext. 1068 · Sevans@onsiteclinical.comSteph Alvarado · Study contact · 800-785-3150 ext. 1034 · salvarado@onsiteclinical.comSteven Bauer, MD · Principal investigatorMatthew Acampora, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Charlotte
- Onsite Clinical Solutions Salisbury · Salisbury, NC 28144Amanda Groce · Study contact · 800-785-3150 ext. 1209 · agroce@onsiteclinical.comMandy Grice · Study contact · 800-785-3150 ext. 1210 · mgrice@onsiteclinical.comDouglas Shellhorn, MD · Principal investigatorKishan Maramraj, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Salisbury
- Wake Forest University Health · Winston-Salem, NC 27157Lauren Middleton · Study contact · 336-713-2748 · Lauren.Middleton@Advocatehealth.orgJanet Hutchens · Study contact · 336-716-1715 · Janet.Hutchens@Advocatehealth.orgBarbara Nye, MD · Principal investigatorRebecca Wells, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Winston-Salem
NE
- Nebraska Medical Center · Omaha, NE 68198Jana Ocken · Study contact · 402-552-2672 · jocken@unmc.eduMorgan Hurtz · Study contact · 402-552-6233 · mhurtz@unmc.eduBeth Hartman, MD · Principal investigatorAutumn Nye, APRN · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Omaha
NJ
- JFK Neuroscience Institute · Edison, NJ 08820Priyanka Basnet, BSN, RN · Study contact · 732-321-7010 · priyanka.basnet@hmhn.orgShriya Patel · Study contact · shp228@lehigh.eduBrian Gerhardstein, MD · Principal investigatorEmad Noor, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Edison
NV
- Advanced Research Institute Reno · Reno, NV 89511Amber Thaxton · Study contact · 775-502-1616 · amber@advresearch.orgMatthew Mehlhaff · Study contact · 877-577-3732 · matt@advresearch.orgDennis T. Yamamoto, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in Reno
NY
- Nuvance Health Institute · Kingston, NY 12401Rishitha Thanikonda · Study contact · 845-790-5848 ext. 51256 · rishitha.thanikonda@nuvancehealth.orgOlatunde Olaniyi · Study contact · 845-790-5848 ext. 51256 · olatunde.olaniyi@nuvancehealth.orgJulio Vieira, MD · Principal investigatorJanet Tamai, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Kingston
- Northwell Health · Manhasset, NY 11030Carmen Lima · Study contact · 516-472-5807 · clima5@northwell.eduNicholas Zumba · Study contact · 516-319-7654 · nzumba@northwell.eduNoah Rosen, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in Manhasset
- Mt Sinai Icahn School of Medicine · New York, NY 10029Sarah Kurtz, PA-C · Study contact · 917-273-1674 · sarah.kurtz@mssm.eduMaya Campbell · Study contact · Maya.campbell@mssm.eduBridget Mueller, MD · Principal investigatorAnna Pace, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in New York
OH
- Ohio State University Wexner Medical Center · Columbus, OH 43210Kemba Johnson · Study contact · 614-293-8000 · Kemba.Johnson@osumc.eduKevin Weber, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in Columbus
OR
- Advanced Research Institute · Portland, OR 97223Jessica Weed · Study contact · 503-610-0033 · jessicaw@advresearch.orgRachael Widner · Study contact · 503-610-0033 · rachael@advresearch.orgWalter Goebel, MD · Principal investigatorJim Bergthold, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Portland
PA
- University of Pennsylvania · Philadelphia, PA 19107Gina Siermine · Study contact · 215-829-5159 · Gina.Siermine@PennMedicine.upenn.eduAllie Oliver · Study contact · 215-829-7104 · Alexandria.Oliver@pennmedicine.upenn.eduEric Kaiser, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in Philadelphia
RI
- Brown University Health · Providence, RI 02903Deepica Chaudhary · Study contact · 401-606-4655 · DChaudhary@brownhealth.orgAlexis DeMarco · Study contact · 401-606-4651 · ADemarco@brownhealth.orgRoderick Spears, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in Providence
TN
- Vanderbilt Medical Center · Nashville, TN 37215Jordon Winn · Study contact · 615-421-6094 · Jordon.winn@vumc.orgJoy Derwenskus, MD · Principal investigatorFrancesca Bagnato, MS · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Nashville
TX
- DHR Health Headache Center · McAllen, TX 78504Leah Picazo · Study contact · 956-362-2234 · Leah.Picazo@dhrhealth.comAlexis Valencia · Study contact · Alexis.Valencia@dhrhealth.comGloria Simms, MD · Principal investigatorMore trials in McAllen
UT
- Advanced Research Institute Ogden · Ogden, UT 84405Stephanie Church · Study contact · 801-409-2040 · stephanie@advresearch.orgNoah Nielsen · Study contact · 801-409-2040 · noah@advresearch.orgMichael Woolman, MD · Principal investigatorJonathan N Winkfield, PA-C · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Ogden
WI
- Marshfield Clinic Research Institute · Marshfield, WI 54449Megan Johnson · Study contact · 715-389-5473 · johnson.megan.a@marshfieldresearch.orgStacy Welter · Study contact · 715-221-6492 · welter.stacy@marshfieldresearch.orgJeff VanWormer, PhD · Principal investigatorLee Cody, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Marshfield
- The Medical College of Wisconsin · Milwaukee, WI 53226Karen Schmidt, RN · Study contact · (414) 955-0674 · kaschmidt@mcw.eduVictoria Ochotnicky · Study contact · (414) 955-0659 · vochotnicky@mcw.eduGlen Soloman, MD · Principal investigatorJames Murtha, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Milwaukee
WV
- West Virginia University · Morgantown, WV 26506Lauren Chase RN, BSN · Study contact · 304-598-4000 ext. 79418 · lauren.chase@wvumedicine.orgBethany Moore, RPh · Study contact · Bethany.moore2@wvumedicine.orgKristina Lopez, MD · Principal investigatorDavid Watson, MD · Sub-investigatorMore trials in Morgantown